Subarus are less dependable than Toyotas overall. They consistently receive superior ratings from Consumer Reports and J.D. Power and have more distinctions and awards across all models. Toyota provides a model that has received great ratings and will meet your demands, whether you’re searching for an all-wheel-drive sedan or a truck with off-roading skills.
The MSRP of several Toyota automobiles is lower than Subaru’s. Additionally, all trim levels of the majority of their vehicles come standard with amenities like adaptive cruise control, Android Auto, and Apple CarPlay. They also have Toyota’s Safety Sense, which is a collection of security features like pre-collision and lane-keeping assistance. They become a better overall value and are much more reliable on the road in terms of both their mechanical and feature set.
In This Article...
Which has a higher value: Subaru or Toyota?
Toyota loses the title of Best Resale Value Brand to Subaru. Each of the 2020 models of the Outback, Forester, Crosstrek, Impreza, and Legacy wins a segment prize.
Your new car loses value as soon as you leave the dealer’s lot. However, some automakers, such as Subaru, will not depreciate as much as the majority of automakers and will maintain their worth the best. In terms of depreciation across its whole lineup, Subaru has the lowest rate, according to Kelly Blue Book’s (KBB) Best Resale Value Awards. Additionally, the Japanese automaker took home five individual KBB awards in 2020.
In 2011, 2015, and 2016 Subaru received the Best Brand award four times. Toyota loses the championship to Subaru after winning it the previous three years, in 2017, 2018, and 2019. In addition to winning Best Mainstream Brand, the 2020 Subaru Outback gets Best Midsize SUV 2-row, Best Compact SUV, Best Subcompact SUV, Best Compact Car, Best Legacy, and Best Midsize Car. The Subaru Crosstrek also wins Best Subcompact SUV.
The 2020 model-year automobiles that won the KBB’s Best Resale Value Awards had their predicted retained value through the first five years of ownership recognized. Consumers may now be informed that Subaru automobiles keep their value better than those from any other carmaker, including Toyota, thanks to the most recent KBB honors. When you trade in your car after three to five years, this could make the most difference. Compared to vehicles from other automakers, you’ll get more for your trade-in.
Depreciation (loss of value), which indicates to buyers which vehicle will have the best resale value, is often your principal expense when owning your new automobile if you intend to retain it for three to five years.
Subarus cost more to fix than Toyotas, do you think?
Subarus typically cost more to maintain over time than other non-luxury cars. This is because Subarus often cost more to repair than vehicles from Toyota and Ford, which are equivalent.
Numerous benefits come with owning a Subaru. They generally get decent gas mileage and provide a nicer cabin at a lower price than other manufacturers. They also provide all-wheel drive, which is excellent if you live in a situation where it is required.
They will occasionally require repairs, just like any car. As one of the more reliable vehicles on the market, Subarus won’t break down very frequently. However, when a part needs to be changed, it will cost you slightly more than it would in a vehicle of a comparable make.
Adding to the importance of car maintenance? obtaining the best auto insurance, which Jerry can assist you in doing.
Jerry is an app, so there’s no need to sit across from him at a desk! After signing up, which takes less than a minute, you will be shown competitive rates from more than 50 leading suppliers. Save money with Jerry and avoid losing coverage.
Why is Subaru so undependable?
So what has changed that might have rendered Subarus less dependable than they were in the early 2010s, when their popularity was at its peak. This might be the case for a few different reasons.
One is that, in comparison to some of its rivals, Subaru doesn’t provide as many models. This implies that if the reliability of one or two models declines, the brand as a whole may suffer. For instance, the entire Subaru lineup and their position in the reliability tables will be impacted if the dependability ratings for the Outback and Legacy decline.
Subaru is impacted differently than brands with a far wider variety of vehicles, like BMW and Mercedes-Benz. The reliability of the Mercedes-Benz or BMW brand as a whole won’t be significantly affected if one or two of the brand’s models become less dependable.
This has undoubtedly been the case with Subaru. The Legacy and the Outback have experienced issues, including sounds, leaks, and issues with the in-car technology.
They might also be viewed as less dependable in the UK because they are expensive to fix when they do go wrong.
ReliabilityIndex’s most recent statistics (2018) state that the average cost of repairs for all Subaru models is $562.37.
We cannot disregard Subaru’s high repair expenses because many customers would want to take this into consideration. The lack of Subarus in the UK is one of the factors contributing to the high cost of repairs. Because of this, their parts are more expensive and less widely available. Particularly if they need to be ordered from another country, this is true. This raises the cost of repairs, which in turn lowers reliability. Because of this, they might be viewed as less reliable and more expensive to fix in the UK. Simply put, it’s because they are less typical. Additionally, the cost of labor has significantly climbed in recent years. As a result, brands like Subaru have a lower reliability rating.
The issues that the Outback and Legacy have experienced with in-car technology are one of the main reasons Subaru reliability has declined. Since the early 2000s, dependability has generally declined in a number of makes and models for this reason.
Today’s autos feature a ton of innovative and sophisticated technology. While this seems fantastic on paper and is also extremely cool when you initially obtain the car, you may encounter issues with it in the future. There are a lot of moving parts, and they may have an impact on your car’s overall dependability. The cost of maintaining or upgrading the technology may further reduce its reliability.
Nevertheless, Subaru is not the most unreliable brand out there by any means, and they continue to build reliable vehicles that many motorists have no problems at all with.
What Subaru should I stay away from?
The two Subaru years to steer clear of are 2009 and 2013, as these years saw significant redesigns that resulted in large safety recalls for several models.
The Subaru brand is recognized as being connected with dependability, powerful performance, and the passion put into each vehicle. But while Subaru has revamped and reinvented its cars over the years, a few model years in particular have been plagued by mechanical issues and safety recalls.
Which automaker has the best reputation?
Toyota
As the most dependable automaker, Toyota takes the top spot. Toyota cars are renowned for their durability and have a longer average lifespan than any other brand. Toyotas are so well made that their maintenance and repair expenses are below average, which helps explain why they stay on the road for such a long time.
There are well-known Toyota automobiles in a variety of segments that exhibit long-term dependability. The Toyota Sienna minivan, the Toyota Tacoma pickup truck, the Toyota Highlander and Toyota RAV4 crossover SUVs, the Toyota Prius and Camry hybrid, and the Toyota Corolla and Toyota Camry are a few examples of Toyota vehicles. In fact, the venerable Toyota Land Cruiser SUV also holds the title of being the longest-lasting car overall. In addition to being the most dependable brand, Toyota cars are renowned for having outstanding value retention, which increases the brand’s appeal.
Honda
Honda, a second Japanese company, comes in at number two on the ranking of the most dependable automakers. Honda is renowned for producing durable automobiles that are safe and dependable. Honda offers a wide range of cars that excel in long-term dependability, from SUVs like the Honda CR-V and Honda Pilot to minivans like the Honda Odyssey and sedans like the Honda Accord and Honda Civic. Honda vehicles not only offer some of the best reliability in the business, but they also lead the pack in terms of practicality, get above-average fuel efficiency, and have a number of safety features.
GMC
GMC comes in third. Due to the durability of the GMC Yukon full-size SUV, the GMC Yukon XL, and the GMC Sierra 1500 pickup truck, GMC received a high rating on the list. As the pricier version of Chevrolet, GMC offers refinement and ranks above average for value retention.
- Chevrolet
- Ford
Fifth place goes to Ford, a third American brand. The Ford Expedition full-size SUV, the Ford Explorer, and the Ford F-150 pickup truck all have excellent dependability ratings for the Ford brand. Even as one of the most durable sports vehicles, the Ford Mustang is praised. Because of its dependability, the F-150 has been the best-selling car in the US for more than 40 years. The Sync infotainment system, one of the best-rated among automakers, is found in Ford’s newest models.
A dependable model from a reputable brand will help you get the most out of your investment, regardless of whether you’re buying a new or used automobile. It will also be your best line of defense against exorbitant maintenance and ownership costs. If you’re thinking about buying a car from a brand that isn’t on this list, make sure to look into the model’s dependability. Because trustworthy cars tend to keep their value better than their less dependable competitors, vehicle dependability and reliability are crucial for resale value. And the first step to finding the best car is picking a reputable brand when you start your search for one.
Why is Subaru not well-known?
The issues that the Outback and Legacy have experienced with in-car technology are one of the main reasons Subaru reliability has declined. Since the early 2000s, this has been a common cause of diminishing reliability in a number of brands and models. Today’s autos feature a ton of innovative and sophisticated technology.
Subaru uses Toyota motors, right?
Toyota’s continued increase in interest in Subaru is for a good reason. The more ownership Toyota has over the business, the more control it has on the cars Subaru makes. The two businesses can more easily pool resources because of their similar interest.
The two businesses, according to Auto News, have significant future aspirations. These ambitions include creating a new generation of the Toyota 86 and Subaru BRZ, increasing all-wheel drive technology, and integrating Toyota’s hybrid drivetrain system into more Subaru vehicles.
Even though Toyota does not actually own Subaru, it is increasingly involved in shaping its destiny. It will be fascinating to observe if Toyota keeps increasing its ownership of the business.