It’s probably a frequent practice for individuals who regularly use a manual transmission vehicle. Drivers will skip from third to fifth gear, fourth to sixth gear, and so on rather than rowing through all five or six gears.
Is this method safe to use, though? In the most recent episode of Engineering Explained, the topic was addressed, and the short answer is that it is acceptable to skip gears when upshifting or downshifting. Both exercises should be performed with some background knowledge, though. This may seem obvious to those with years of manual gearbox operation knowledge, but for others, it’s useful information.
It should be noted that while switching gears using a manual transmission, the revs will drop from the high revs to the lower revs more slowly. The car will jerk as it attempts to correct the unbalance if you change from third to fifth gear while releasing the clutch at the same rate as usual. Instead, holding off on releasing the clutch just a little bit longer will maintain everything balanced while the gearbox shifts to a lower rev range.
It becomes a little trickier when downshifting. When switching from a low to a high gear, rev matching is crucial. For instance, shifting from fifth to third may be necessary if you’re on the highway and you want to pass a slower-moving car. The car won’t jerk if the engine and clutch are rev-matched; at worst, the wheels could lock up. The clutch speed and engine speed should be almost perfectly in sync at this point. Additionally, nobody looks nice while downshifting and revving a car. You’ll also gradually begin to see clutch wear.
Finally, the following often asked topic is addressed: Can you begin going from a stop in a gear other than first? Yes, once more, however there will be a minor increase in clutch wear. While the engine and clutch match more slowly in second gear, they can be totally released in first gear at a slower speed. Although it’s not the best course of action, there are no unfavorable side effects either. Having said that, happy moving.
In This Article...
Is braking or downshifting preferable?
Stick-shifters frequently disagree on whether to downshift or apply the brakes. Downshifting proponents contend that it prevents brake wear and tear, while braking proponents counter that it saves money on petrol and relieves worry about possible engine and gearbox problems.
People downshift (or engine brake) mostly in order to save money on their brake system. The driver may end up saving quite a deal of money over time if brake pads, discs, and rotors are not need to be purchased separately. Let’s face it, there’s also the excitement a motorist experiences when they hear the rumbling of a downshifting engine!
Downshifting, meanwhile, puts more stress on the transmission and engine. Compared to the brake system, these parts are much more expensive to replace. Additionally, research has demonstrated that engine braking uses more gas than standard braking. Even while the additional petrol cost might not seem like much, the overall savings could add up.
You should usually avoid downshifting unless you’re on a climb where repeated braking would be impractical. When you are driving, it may be entertaining to hear the exhaust rumble, but it won’t be entertaining to learn that your engine or transmission needs to be replaced.
When stopped, should automatic transmission go into neutral?
It is foolish to put the car in neutral at a stoplight to save fuel. Any gasoline savings would be quite little because stop lights only last a short while.
The story is not over yet. Every time you get to a stop light, you will have to change gears, putting extra wear on them. They could need to be replaced sooner than you anticipate.
By leaving the motor in drive and applying the brakes at the stoplight, you can avoid all of this. Instead of grinding the gears, you will only need to let off the brakes and keep driving when the light turns green.
Is a VW Golf simple to operate?
Driving the Volkswagen Golf is simple. The Golf is one of the greatest vehicles for new drivers to utilize because it is one of the easiest vehicles to operate.
Is the VW Golf a reliable first vehicle?
So that they may fully focus on the task of driving, they need their car to make their lives as simple as possible. We chose the Volkswagen Golf as the 2019 recipient of our Best Car for New Drivers award because it is one of the most user-friendly vehicles money can buy.
When you brake, do you need to engage the clutch?
Switching gears is made possible by the clutch, which also disconnects the wheels from the engine and cuts off electricity to the wheels. So if you want to stop, clutching when braking is absolutely vital.
What nine stages are involved in operating a manual car?
With your left foot, gradually start to release some of the clutch pressure. Depending on the car, you might feel it start to move forward slowly. Your right foot should start to press the accelerator as you slowly release the clutch. This is a sensitive motion. Keep your car from moving forward too quickly. Keep in mind that first gear is only intended for speeds of up to fifteen miles per hour.
When should a gear change be made?
Find the clutch before starting the car. When changing gears, the clutch must be depressed! Practice putting your left foot on the clutch pedal and releasing it. You’ll start to notice when the clutch is engaged or disengaged (in your foot).
Depress the clutch all the way once you’ve gotten a feel for it, then shift into first gear. Then, while depressing the gas pedal, start releasing the clutch with your left foot (this is often referred to as “feathering”). If the car were running, you would start to move.
Release your foot from the gas and continue in the same manner to shift into higher gears:
- Activate the clutch
- Change to the next highest gear with the shifter.
- Release the clutch while applying pressure to the gas pedal.
You essentially do the same thing when you downshift. While shifting, take your foot off the gas pedal.
- Put the gearshift in the next lower position.
- Release the clutch while gradually depressing the gas pedal.
While the engine is off, practice shifting up and down while depressing and releasing the clutch.
You must depress the clutch to enter neutral and come to a complete halt. After that, release the clutch pedal. Typically, you should change gears when your vehicle hits 2,500 to 3,000 RPM. By sound and sensation, you will eventually be able to shift when necessary.
Can you operate an automatic vehicle in manual mode?
First off, it should be noted that driving your automatic car in manual mode generally doesn’t cause the car to go through more significant wear and tear, unless you unintentionally overtax the system or accidentally switch the gear shifter back into another mode while you’re moving, like neutral, park, or reverse.
Overtaxing the system, the first of these two issues, is a simple mistake made by drivers who have never used a manual transmission and are therefore untrained in shifting through gears. But even if they instantly switch to automatic vehicles after passing their test, the majority of young drivers in the UK still learn to drive in manual vehicles.
Due to this sort of car’s gear shifter’s design, the second issue is similarly uncommon. In order to allow you to change gears without mistakenly pushing the lever too far back up into another gear setting, the shifter’s manual mode is typically positioned to one side. However, when operating an automated vehicle in manual mode, all drivers should be mindful of the following:
Can you change to manual while operating a vehicle?
A query regarding using a modern automatic transmission with the manual option came from a reader. His query is as follows:
“Top Gear PH, hello! In an automatic vehicle, is it acceptable to switch from drive to manual (+/-) while I’m cruising? I’m hoping you can respond to my query. So excited! I’m grateful.”
There is nothing to worry about and you can. This is what these contemporary automatic transmissions with a manual mode are designed to do. It was designed to go from automated to manual mode, even while traveling at a high speed.
A few improvements to the automatic transmission have been made in the last ten years or so. Modern automatic transmissions now have a manual mode that allows the driver to manually shift gears, a feature that was first offered in exotic automobiles. However, unlike a true manual transmission, which uses a pedal to drive a hydraulic or cable-controlled clutch, modern manual transmissions just have switches or a shifter that needs to be tugged or pushed to change speeds.
With these gearboxes, the driver is free to choose a certain gear whenever they want. The ability to select one gear and maintain it gives the driver additional control in manual mode. The more control you have as a driver, the better.
Here are a few situations where using manual mode is beneficial:
Can you shift from 3rd to 1st?
Yes, it is advised to be able to skip gears when traveling up or down in a modern manual transmission. For instance, when accelerating, you can switch from first to third gear as needed, however third gear may struggle owing to low engine revs.
How can I easily go from gear 1 to gear 2?
Keep your hand on the gear lever with your palm facing away from you to shift from first to second gear. Lightly press the left side of the gear lever to prevent it from springing back to the middle neutral position before pulling the lever straight back.
Is it acceptable to begin in manual second gear?
Particularly with a manual transmission, drivers will often begin in second speed for a variety of reasons. Perhaps the first gear is too short, or slick roads call for slower acceleration to prevent tire spinning.
Fear not, Engineering Explained’s Jason Fenske is here to explain when starting in second gear might be a good idea. In order to provide a more detailed understanding of what is happening with your gearbox and clutch, he also takes the time to clarify the distinctions between manual and automatic transmissions.
Jason can think of one situation in which starting a car with a manual transmission in second gear is actually sensible. That’s if a car is travelling downhill from a dead stop. As the car is already accelerating in this situation due to momentum, shifting into second gear is simple. Going downhill, a first-to-second change would be exceedingly brief. It therefore makes sense.
Other times, it can appear like starting in second gear is simpler, but there are more factors at play that might mess up the process, particularly the clutch. To make his point, Jason performs a straightforward flywheel and clutch demonstration. Let’s take an example where the clutch is disengaged and the engine speed is 1,000 rpm. In this case, the car just needs to accelerate to 5 mph in first gear to fully engage the clutch and prevent slippage. Since the vehicle must travel at least 10 mph in second gear, the clutch will slip significantly more as the vehicle speeds up. In the end, this will cause the clutch to wear down faster.
The ideal practice is to keep RPMs low in order to prevent wheel spin, even though it’s not the worst thing for the clutch (it is after all intended to handle sliding).
It’s a different situation when using an automatic transmission. Less is at risk for second-gear starts since a torque converter manages power transfer from the engine to the transmission. A spline is instructed to transfer power to the transmission by the flex plate’s ability to drive fluid to one side of the torque converter as it rotates. Since there is no clutch plate to wear out, the coupling is entirely fluid, and there is no real risk. To help keep the tires from spinning on slick pavement, the majority of automatic transmissions have a W (Winter) mode that starts off in second gear.
So starting in second gear is generally not a problem for drivers. However, those operating a vehicle with a manual transmission need to practice their footwork.