When comparing the performance of the BMW X3 and X5, things become a little more intriguing. To list all 0-60 timings, 1/4 mile times, etc. would be impossible due to the sheer number of models, engines, and other aspects. The X5 delivers more power and performance overall though. Inline-4 or inline-6 engines are frequently seen in X3 models. The inline-6 in the X5 base models is followed by V8 variants. However, a performance X3 model will easily outperform an X5 base model at a comparable price. Let’s give a little example:
- 2022 X3 M40i – MSRP $57,800
- 382 horsepower, 4.4 seconds to 60
- 2022 X5 sDrive40i – MSRP of $59,400
- 335 horsepower, 5.3 seconds from 0 to 60
The B58 3.0L inline-6 turbo engine powers both versions. However, in addition to all of the other BMW M enhancements, the X3 M40i gets a better tune for greater power. It will have a little lower MSRP than a base model X5 and a superior performance SAV. When comparing models, the X5 is undoubtedly better because the X5 M50i’s 4.4L twin turbo V8 produces 523 horsepower. However, that will cost you a whopping $82,800 or more.
The point is that performance can vary considerably, and one model isn’t necessarily superior to another. When comparing base models, such as the M40i and M50i or the X3M and X5M, the X5 is usually the better, more potent option. Budgets aren’t taken into account, and there are X3 versions that are less expensive or comparable in price that perform better than X5 ones.
Model for model, the X5 is typically the faster, more potent, and better-performing SUV. However, when you consider the cost of the vehicles, an X3 can offer superior performance at a comparable price.
In This Article...
Both are suggested by Consumer Reports, but not J.D. Power
Consumer Reports recommends both the BMW X3 and X5. The X3 received high marks for its handling and quiet interior, but reliability received criticism. The X5 is the same. Both of the SUVs’ most recent redesigns, the X5 for 2019 and the X3 for 2022, witnessed advancements over the models they replaced. In its initial quality study, J.D. Power did not place either in the top three in their respective classes, although they did place highly.
MPG – City, 21 – 23 MPG, 16 – 21 MPG; MPG – Highway, 26 – 29 MPG, 22 – 26 MPG; 2023 BMW X5 Review; 5 – 7 seats; 5 – 5 seats; 5 – 7 seats; Cargo
Which BMW X3 or X5 is superior?
Because it is the bigger of the two, the BMW X5 has a 4.4-liter M Performance V8 engine that can produce up to 523 horsepower, giving it more total power. But the BMW X3 also has a 3.0-liter M Performance I-6 engine that boasts up to 382-horsepower.
What distinctions exist between the BMW X3 and X5 models?
The X3 is a compact SUV, whilst the X5 is a midsize SUV. Only the X5 has an optional third row that increases your seating capacity to seven people, despite the fact that both models can accommodate up to five passengers as standard. Additionally, the X5’s wider interior offers more cargo room.
For a BMW X5, which engine is preferable?
Well, there are a lot of engines available for the X5 of the E70 generation. Each gasoline engine has a good number of issues. However, we advise staying away from the 50i model equipped with the N63 engine. It is the original N63 engine from the E70, which had a lot of problems. The F15 and G05’s later N63 engines offer a notable reliability improvement. The N52 and N62 engines with natural aspiration are probably your best chance for dependability. The N55 engine in the X5 35i versions should be reliable, however there are a few frequent (and pricey) oil leaks in the engine. The X5S63 M’s engine is a robust and dependable engine. However, the X5big M’s brakes, tires, etc. make routine maintenance pricey.
Aside from its engines, the E70 X5 is a fairly dependable vehicle. When compared to the earlier E53, they do contain a few extra electronics. As they age, BMWs can develop electrical gremlins, so keep that in mind. The E70’s steering, brakes, suspension, and transmission are all quite dependable. Additionally, the engines are all excellent on the inside. The components immediately surrounding them, such as the water pumps, expansion tanks, coolant hoses, and seals, are what are problematic. If you know how to do it yourself, most of this stuff isn’t too expensive to fix.
The E70 X5 scores a “OK” overall for dependability. The more expensive parts, such as the transmissions and engine internals, are robust. Everything that surrounds the engine has the potential to become pricey. Additionally, the early E70 machines are getting on in age, which may necessitate more maintenance and repairs.
Better than the BMW X5 or the Audi Q5?
The BMW X5 might be a better choice if you’re seeking for an SUV with spirited engine specifications. However, the Q5 might be a better choice if you’re searching for a car that will go the additional mile because of its more fuel-efficient petrol alternatives. The usual EPA estimates for the BMW X5 are 21 city and 26 highway MPG.
How much larger is the BMW X5 than the X3?
Size is one of the main factors to take into account when choosing between the BMW X3 and the BMW X5. While the X3 can accommodate five people comfortably, the X5 has an optional third row that can accommodate up to seven people. Another consideration is cargo room; the X5 has more inside space thanks to its greater height, width, and length.
BMW X3 and X5 are the same size.
The size of these SUVs in general is one of the most obvious variations between them. The X3 boasts exceptional fuel efficiency in part because it is the smaller crossover of the two. The X3 is 8.4 inches shorter than the X3, for a total length of 185.9 inches, which is significant for most drivers who want to park their cars inside. The X3 is 4.5 inches narrower than the X5 at its widest point, which is another important aspect. The X5’s size does, however, benefit it in some situations. The X5’s gasoline tank is bigger than the X3’s, with a capacity of 21.9 gallons as opposed to 17.2 gallons. The size of these cars has an impact on interior space as well. On average, the X5 should feel a little roomier. Although both of these SUVs can accommodate 5 passengers rather comfortably, the X5 is a larger car and has more room for both front and back passengers’ shoulders and legs. However, the X5 has a huge advantage when it comes to cargo space, providing 72.3 cubic feet of space when the rear seats are folded down as opposed to the X3’s 62.7 usable cubic feet in the same configuration. However, if you prefer the X3, you won’t notice the difference in passenger space all that much since it only lacks a few inches in terms of legroom and shoulder room while providing even more headroom in the front seats than the BMW X5. If you have things to move, the size of the X5 is more than justified.
BMW X5 dependability
dependable BMW X5 The BMW X5 is a trustworthy car you can depend on thanks to its exceptional build quality and fit and finish. Looking back at the statistics for the 2021 model, prominent data analytics and consumer intelligence organization J.D. Power awarded the X5 a score of 81 out of 100.
What is the Mercedes version of the BMW X3?
Prices for the 2022 BMW X3 range from $43,700 to $69,900, not including a $995 destination fee, for consumers. BMW offers three basic variants of its small luxury SUV. The popular X3 30i is available with rear-wheel drive (RWD) sDrive30i or all-wheel drive (AWD) xDrive30i and boasts a turbocharged 4-cylinder engine. The price increases by $2,000 when AWD is chosen.
Choose the BMW X3 M40i, which boasts a turbocharged 6-cylinder engine and standard AWD, if you want something with more panache. BMW also offers the X3 M, which features an even more potent 6-cylinder and a modified suspension, for those looking for a high-performance compact SUV. The X3 xDrive30e plug-in hybrid model is no longer being produced by the carmaker as of 2022.
The 2022 X3 features a variety of linked services, including remote locking and engine starting, live emergency support, concierge services, digital key access, and even a driving recorder, as is characteristic of small luxury SUVs. A Wi-Fi hotspot is also available. To activate desired features, you might need to make additional purchases. After that, you’ll need to manage them on the My BMW app.
If you own an X3 for the first three years or 36,000 miles, BMW will provide free scheduled maintenance.
A 2022 Mercedes-Benz GLC costs between $43,850 and $85,600, not including a $1,005 destination fee, if you’re in the market for one. Mercedes provides both normal and “coupe” body types for its small premium SUV. Both are 5-seater, 4-door utility vehicles, but the GLC Coupe is pricier and has a more svelte, curved roofline. (BMW sells it as a separate vehicle and offers a similar feature in the X4)
The 2022 Mercedes GLC comes in three different variants. The GLC 300, a 4-cylinder turbocharged vehicle, comes first. Rear-wheel drive is standard, but you can upgrade to 4Matic AWD for $2,000 more (AWD is standard on the GLC 300 Coupe). Customers seeking more thrill should consider the Mercedes-AMG GLC 43, which comes standard with 4Matic AWD and a turbo V6 engine.
The BMW X3 M’s major competition is the high-performance 2022 Mercedes-AMG GLC 63, which sits at the top of the lineup. It comes in ordinary and somewhat hotter S states of tune and features a turbocharged V8 engine under the hood. Previously only available in a coupe body style, the GLC 63 is now offered in both the standard SUV and coupe body types for 2022.
Every 2022 Mercedes-Benz GLC includes a free, three-year subscription to the Mercedes me connect network of linked services. Remote access, emergency assistance, quick access to roadside services, and Wi-Fi are among the features that are comparable to those on the BMW. A warning will be sent if another car strikes your GLC while it is parked thanks to a parking damage detection system.
Scheduled maintenance is not provided without charge by Mercedes. Instead, customers can buy prepaid plans from the provider.
Are BMW X3 vehicles dependable?
To help you find the optimal balance of price AND dependability, CoPilot Compare lays down the pricing and feature differences between BMW X3 model years.
Since the release of the first models in its current generation, the BMW X3 has advanced significantly. The BMW X3 is now commonly regarded as the “luxury SUV that can,” which is even more impressive given that it is in direct competition with vehicles like the Mercedes-Benz GLC-Class and Audi Q5.
BMW may be a renowned company, but their cars, including the BMW X3, aren’t always dependable. The X3 line-up receives a 2.5 out of 5.0 reliability rating from RepairPal. Do yourself a favor and continue reading if you have your eye on a used BMW X3.
We quickly review the BMW X3 years to stay away from as well as the ones that are genuinely worth your time and money in today’s automobile comparison guide.
What is the BMW X5’s equivalent in the Audi?
Exterior & Interior Design of the Audi Q5. Although the BMW SAV can accommodate seven passengers with an optional third-row seat, both the BMW X5 and Audi Q5 are five-seat SUVs.
Are the engines in the X3 and X5 the same?
The BMW X3 is a high-end crossover SUV with a 2.0-liter TwinPower Turbo 4-cylinder engine that produces 248 horsepower. If you like the rush, the 3.0-liter, 6-cylinder engine in the M Performance model, which is also standard in the BMW X5, increases horsepower.