Audi is a clear choice when it comes to performance and dependability since Mercedes only offers all-wheel drive on a few of its models while Audi is all about it. Speaking of which, in a road test conducted by Consumer Reports, Audi defeated Mercedes as the most dependable brand.
In This Article...
Mercedes or Audi: which maintenance costs are less?
If you’re deciding between an Audi and a comparable vehicle, you might be curious about how Audi maintenance expenses compare to those of other manufacturers. In comparison to Audi vehicles, BMW, Lexus, and Mercedes-Benz vehicles provide comparable degrees of luxury and price points.
- Compared to Audi, the maintenance cost for a BMW is $5,400 higher at $17,800.
- Audi vs. Mercedes-Benz maintenance costs: Mercedes-Benz automobiles require maintenance that costs $12,900, $500 more than Audi.
- Audi costs $5,400 more to maintain than Lexus, which has a $7,000 maintenance cost. The least expensive premium automobile to maintain is typically a Lexus.
Between Audi, Mercedes, and BMW, which is better?
Audi frequently beats out rivals if you want to put appearances above everything else. BMW is the best option if you want a joyful, exciting driving experience. Mercedes remains the king of power, safety, and speed.
What makes Mercedes superior to Audi?
Even though both Audi and Mercedes-Benz offer an impressive array of luxury vehicles, Mercedes-Benz just outperforms Audi in terms of reliability. Mercedes-Benz vehicles typically come with greater interior features, better engine options, and higher efficiency.
Are Audis prone to breakdowns?
Everyone is aware that effective marketing can enable someone to sell sand in the Sahara. In order to obtain useful insight into the attitudes and trends in the automotive sector, Warrantywise, the top-rated provider of vehicle warranties in the UK, conducts a thorough amount of research and polls.
Warrantywise polled 750 British drivers to find out which automakers they considered to be the most dependable, and Audi made it into the top 10. Audi actually placed 28th out of 36 brands on their “Dependability Rating” scale for reliability in 2019. Based on the quantity of reported problems and breakdowns, they determined the rating.
Website for auto repair estimates RepairPal determines each brand’s overall score by calculating the frequency and cost of all repairs, including parts and labor. Audi received an average rating of 3.0 out of 5.0 at the time of writing. However, out of 32 car brands, that places the firm in 28th place.
Are Audis durable?
Out of 32 automotive manufactures, Audi is presently ranked 28th in terms of dependability. A well driven and maintained Audi should last between 10 and 13 years, or 150,000 to 200,000 kilometres. Audis are renowned for their technology, style, performance, and beautifully designed interiors. They also have an all-wheel drive system called Quattro.
Although the Audi brand dates back to 1899, it wasn’t until Volkswagen acquired the company in the late 1960s that the automobiles started to become well-known internationally. This fast car has always been at the forefront of technology.
Long before other automakers, the business started conducting crash tests, and in 2010, their first completely autonomous car successfully completed the 20-kilometer Pikes Peak circuit without a driver.
Despite the fact that Audi has many positive qualities, its dependability is not one of them. Audi is not an exception to the rule that high performance requires hefty upkeep.
What is the top German automobile?
It’s safe to say that a significant portion of German pride is entwined in the country’s powerful automobile sector, whose core brands are now titans of the international marketplace that shape consumer behavior throughout the globe. The German manufacturers appear to grasp what people want from their automobiles and how we use them to represent our personalities, more so than the engineering passion, the unique requirements of its local audience, or even the famed limit-free Autobahns.
Of course, the effect goes beyond Germany’s borders as these firms continue to have a presence there by incorporating regional brands into their product lines, as Volkswagen did with Bentley and BMW did with Rolls-Royce. Here, we examine some of the best German vehicles now on the market and how each one reflects the values of its particular manufacturer.
Are Mercedes-Benzes trustworthy?
Currently, Mercedes-Benz provides more than 20 different car types in the US, ranging from sedans to SUVs and everything in between. A base-model vehicle will cost roughly $33,000 if you decide to buy new. A base-model SUV will cost you about $36,000, but you could easily spend up to $100,000 on the Benz of your dreams. Here is a brief overview of the Benz options:
SUVs, as well as the G-Class Sedans and Wagons, GLA, GLB, GLC, GLE, and GLS
The Mercedes Maybach Coupes, the A-Class, C-Class, E-Class, and S-Class
AMG GT Convertibles and Roadsters, CLA, C-Class, E-Class, CLS, and S-Class
SLC, SL Roadster, AMG GT, C-Class, E-Class, and S-Class Cabriolet
There is no denying that Mercedes-Benz produces stunning automobiles that are classy and ageless, appealing to everyday people, famous people, and even the Pope! There are many Mercedes-Benz options accessible in both the new and used automobile markets, so if you’re eager to turn your goal of owning a Mercedes-Benz into a reality, you’re in luck. So let’s get started. Let’s discuss dependability.
Mercedes Reliability Rating
How trustworthy are Mercedes-Benz automobiles? They have an average dependability rating, according to RepairPal. The average Mercedes-Benz Reliability Rating is a 3, which is neither the best nor the worst.
Mercedes-Benz vehicles have average ownership expenses of roughly $900 year, which is higher than the $652 average for all other models. This covers both planned and unforeseen repairs.
Unscheduled repairs require an average of 0.7 repair visits per year, compared to 0.4 for all models. Additionally, an average of 13% of repairs on all Mercedes-Benz models are deemed severe. Comparatively, the likelihood of major difficulties in all models is 12 percent.
The statistics from RepairPal about average cost, frequency, and severity of repairs is based on data from more than 300 different models, not all of which fall within the same class group as a Mercedes-Benz. This is significant to keep in perspective.
For instance, data from all makes and models from companies like Honda, Nissan, and Toyota as well as some luxury brands like BMW, Audi, and of course Mercedes-Benz are considered for determining rankings and the average cost of repairs. Therefore, even though the Benz costs a little more to buy and operate, it is comparable to other high-end vehicles like the BMW, whose repairs actually cost more.
To make apples-to-apples comparisons, we looked at what Consumer Reports had to say about the C-Class and E-Class sedans, the brand’s two most well-known models. By way of
Consumer Reports gave the C-Class and E-Class vehicles a “Recommended” rating for dependability. Both the C- and E-Class models have consistently scored a 3 or higher on Consumer Reports’ scale of projected reliability over the past ten years, earning an average predicted reliability of 3.7 for the C-Class and 3.9 for the E-Class over that same period. Out of 17 luxury compact automobiles, the C-Class came in at number five, and the E-Class came in at number six.
Consequently, keep in mind that a Mercedes-Benz is not your typical car even though it may cost more to purchase one than the ordinary vehicle.
Going the Distance
Even after 100,000 miles, are Mercedes reliable? Depends on who you ask, I suppose. In actuality, if you take good care of your Mercedes-Benz, it will take good care of you and travel up to 100,000 miles!
This entails adhering to a routine repair and maintenance plan, refueling your Benz using the suggested gas, and getting your Mercedes in as soon as a problem appears to have it looked at. Like other vehicles, it is advised to get your Mercedes serviced by a licensed and authorized Mercedes-Benz mechanic. Make sure to find a reputable independent Mercedes-Benz repair specialist who will give you and your Benz the attention you both need if you’re not having your Mercedes-Benz serviced at the dealership. If you take good care of it, your Mercedes can easily reach 100,000.
Fun fact: Mercedes-Benz honors high mileage with an award. Owners of Mercedes-Benz Classic vehicles with at least 155,000 miles on them receive the Mercedes-Benz Classic High Mileage Award! Mercedes-Benz also celebrates mileage milestones of 310k, 466k, 621k, and 1,000,000 kilometers! (Yeah, it has six zeros, making it a million miles!)
It’s difficult to give a definitive answer to the question “Are Mercedes trustworthy beyond 100,000 km.” You must conduct your own research. Look into the car’s past to see if it received the proper maintenance and care.
No matter the mileage, it is a good idea to have a car inspected before buying a used one to make sure everything is functioning as it should and to verify that genuine Mercedes-Benz parts, as well as filters and lubricants, were used if a repair was necessary.
Research any problem codes related to the used Mercedes you are considering as well. It is advised that your Mercedes-Benz repair professional have a fault code scanner for the inspection. These fault codes, often known as DTCs or Diagnostic Trouble Codes, are indications of system faults in your Mercedes. This is not always the case with older models, especially if you’re looking at one with more than 100k miles on it. In newer vehicles, these codes will result in a dash light or error message. If there are any significant electrical or technological issues that could result in future expensive repairs, you can find out by scanning for codes.
You shouldn’t be shocked to find a lot of secondhand Mercedes vehicles with high mileagethis is a sign of Mercedes-Benz dependability. This is because the Mercedes-running Benz’s gear is of high quality, expertly crafted, and durable. And although though some people might advise against purchasing a car with more than 100,000 miles on it, this isn’t always the case. You may be able to discover a good price on an older Benz if you do your homework and adequate research.
Common Mercedes-Benz Reliability Problems
There will obviously be problems with some models, just like with any make and model, irrespective of the brand. A list of typical issues that may affect your Mercedes-dependability Benz’s is provided below. The details for three of Mercedes-most Benz’s well-known models are provided here, courtesy of RepairPal.
Problems with Mercedes C300 Reliability On the RepairPal Reliability scale, the C300 had a reliability rating of 3.5 out of 5, which is above average. The average cost of repairs per year is $739.
driveshaft flex discs with cracks
These damaged components will result in excessive driveshaft movement and vibration, which will be audible through the vehicle’s center floor. If these are not fixed, it could lead to damage to the driveshaft center support bearing or, in the worst case, the transmission or differential. Model years impacted: 20082011; 71,330 miles on the average; $143180 for a general diagnostic.
Back of the cylinder heads with oil seepage
However, seepage and/or leaking are caused by the plastic expansion plugs that are found on the back of the cylinder heads. Seepage and/or leaking are sometimes misdiagnosed as leaking valve covers. The access ports to the camshafts are sealed off by these plugs. Unattended oil leaks will eventually flow down the back of the engine and onto the ground. Every 60,000 miles, they should be replaced; replacement is easy and should be a part of routine maintenance. Model years impacted: 20082011; 113,165 average miles
Brake pads that are noisy or worn out could need to be replaced before they should.
Around the 50% wear point, owners claimed that their brakes began to squeak, causing the brake rotor to become uneven and develop a lip at the outside edge. This necessitates replacing both the braking rotors and pads. impacted model years: 20082010, 20122014 | Mileage on average: 20,000,050,000
ABS modulator failure
Modulator of the anti-lock brake system (ABS) fails early owing to contaminated brake fluid. It is advised to flush the brake fluid every two years to prevent this issue. impacted model years: 20082010 | Brake bleeding costs $126159.
Issues with Mercedes E350 Reliability The RepairPal Reliability scale gives the E350 a reliability rating of 3.5 out of 5, which is above average. The average cost of repairs per year is $788.
Uneven shifting
Vehicles with the 7-speed automatic transmission may have jerky shifting from first to second gear, and from third to second or first gear, according to reports of Mercedes-Benz gear shift issues. A malfunctioning internal component is the cause of the jerky shifting. The transmission must be taken out and disassembled in order to make the required repairs. affected model years: 20062016; affected mileage: 73,61594877
defective solenoid for the camshaft adjuster
The failure of the camshaft adjuster solenoid or the illuminating of the Check Engine Light indicator, as well as other drivability issues, are caused by faults with the camshaft position sensor. In order to provide detailed repair guidance based on the recorded fault codes, Mercedes has issued service bulletins on these problems. Models impacted: 20062012 | Mileage: 86,04592,031 | Diagnostic and testing fees for check engine light indicators: $143$180
Crankshaft position sensor failure
Engine performance problems that result in stalling and/or “This failed crankshaft position sensor is the cause of the crank no start error. Model years impacted include 20062010; 20142016; average mileage is 85,665; and the cost to diagnose a no start is $143180.
front thrust link bushings with cracks
Due to the fact that these bushings are loaded with fluid to help minimize vibration, when they fracture, oil will seep out and, along with the excessive suspension movement, will lead to uneven and early tire wear. Model years impacted: 20062011; 78,810 miles on average; $143 for a general diagnostic. $180
Problems with Mercedes S550 Reliability The RepairPal Dependability Scale gives the S550 a reliability rating of 2 out of 5, which is below average. $1,249 is the typical annual repair expense.
A failing HVAC blower motor
Water infiltration via the cabin air filter regions after heavy rain or snow is a common cause of blower failure. It is important to swap out the defective motor as soon as possible. Models impacted include 20072010, 2013, 2014, and 2016; average mileage is 70,426; and the replacement blower motor costs $735. $755
defective solenoid for the camshaft adjuster
In addition to other drivability concerns, a malfunctioning camshaft adjuster solenoid or worn timing chain/balance shaft components are caused by problems with the camshaft position sensor. In order to provide detailed repair guidance based on the recorded fault codes, Mercedes has issued service bulletins on these problems. Models impacted: 20072010, 2012; Average Mileage: 92,582; Diagnostic and Testing Fees: $143180
Crankshaft position sensor failure
Engine performance problems that result in stalling and/or “This failed crankshaft position sensor is the cause of the crank no start error. Model years impacted are 20072010; average mileage is 81,051; and the diagnosis fee for a no start is between $143 and $180.
issues with the automatic transmission that led to the drive selector module failing
A malfunctioning selector module may prevent the transmission from shifting into the drive position, causing a loss of gear selection. The drive selector module will need to be changed because this could leave the car stranded. Model years impacted: 20072012; 69,995 average miles; $143180 for a general diagnostic.
driveshaft flex discs with cracks
These damaged components will result in excessive driveshaft movement and vibration, which will be audible through the vehicle’s center floor. If these are not fixed, it could lead to damage to the driveshaft center support bearing or, in the worst case, the transmission or differential. A general diagnosis will cost between $143 and $180 for the model years 2007 to 2010 with an average mileage of 70,363.
Which Mercedes Class Is the Most ReliableA Class Above the Rest? While RepairPal and Consumer Reports give the C-Class and E-Class models ordinary and above average ratings, respectively, the E-Class is a step above. It is noted that the Mercedes E-Class dependability is marginally superior to the Mercedes C-Class reliability, routinely scoring higher in expected reliability than its smaller sibling. The Mercedes-Benz E-Class is one of the most dependable used luxury vehicles on the market right now, according to Consumer Reports.
In particular, the 2009 E350, the most popular model produced that year, drew Consumer Reports’ attention for its gearbox, comfortable ride, and interior and exterior design. For anticipated reliability, this particular model year received a score of 4 out of 5. A 2009 Mercedes-Benz E-Class is available for as little as $7,600.
Check out the 2010, 2014, and 2015 model years if you’re looking for a more recent used E350. Consumer Reports gave these years a 4 out of 5 stars. Furthermore, both the 2012 and 2016 years received a perfect score of 5 out of 5 on Consumer Reports’ anticipated dependability rating, which is important if reliability is your top concern.
olive No matter how well made, things ultimately break down, just as with any other vehicle. Make sure your vehicle is insured because it is not unusual to need to occasionally bring your Mercedes-Benz in for repairs, especially if it has passed its warranty period. Despite the fact that Mercedes-Benz repairs may cost a little more than those for other makes and models, olive has you covered. Olive offers extended warranty options with affordable monthly payments so that you may be ready for the unexpected without going broke.
You are protected with olive, and you can quickly request a quotation online and start protecting yourself right away. In the event that your car isn’t, olive will be your dependable mate. Here are a few advantages to which you can look forward:
There is no wait time beginning with 140,000 miles of coverage no annual mileage restrictions nationwide coverage choices for manageable monthly payments Anytime, cancel
With the support of some of the biggest firms in the insurance sector, we have an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau thanks to our products, customer service, and reputation for quality.