AM-Online has conducted research and created a number of infographics to show which German brands are the most dependable and affordable to repair. The study compares maintenance requirements for BMW, Audi, and Mercedes-Benz under six years of ownership, after six years, and after twelve years. As a result, this generally illustrates how each automaker’s models are over their whole lives.
Under six years, the cost and dependability of every car is relatively the same. This is due to the fact that the vehicles are relatively new, often have less than 100,000 miles on them, and come with a factory-backed guarantee, meaning that there won’t be many significant problems.
Audi still has the most issues and requires the most money to fix, though. Mercedes is the most dependable and, therefore, the most affordable vehicle, placing BMW in the center. Things start to alter after six years. The cars do have a tendency to break down as they accumulate more kilometers and perhaps more owners.
The least dependable and priciest of the three manufacturers is still Audi, while Mercedes continues to be the market leader and BMW remains in the center. Twelve years later, though, things usually settle down again because the automobiles are so old and most customers choose to ignore minor issues.
But when you get down to the smaller particulars, things get a little messier. It wasn’t as simple to compare different car classes, such as the 1 Series/2 Series class, 3 Series class, and 5 Series class. The brands’ positioning didn’t change, but the expenses to repair various models did. For instance, the less priced models of both BMW and Audi were less expensive to fix, which seems relatively normal. However, Mercedes-more Benz’s expensive models were the cheapest to repair, probably due to their greater build quality and dependability.
In This Article...
which is more trustworthy BMW, Mercedes, or Audi?
You can see that BMW performs far better than Mercedes-Benz or Audi. Additionally, it performs much better than the industry standard of 121 issues per 100 vehicles. Audi and Mercedes-Benz both rank lower than the average number of issues per 100 vehicles, even though Mercedes is close to the industry average.
BMW or Audi, which is more dependable?
Despite the great reliability of both BMW and Audi, Audi ultimately prevails because to its extended warranty coverage and additional safety measures.
Is BMW or Audi superior to Mercedes?
Audi frequently beats out rivals if you want to put appearances above everything else. BMW is the best option if you want a joyful, exciting driving experience. Mercedes remains the king of power, safety, and speed.
Mercedes or Audi: which maintenance costs are less?
If you’re deciding between an Audi and a comparable vehicle, you might be curious about how Audi maintenance expenses compare to those of other manufacturers. In comparison to Audi vehicles, BMW, Lexus, and Mercedes-Benz vehicles provide comparable degrees of luxury and price points.
- Compared to Audi, the maintenance cost for a BMW is $5,400 higher at $17,800.
- Audi vs. Mercedes-Benz maintenance costs: Mercedes-Benz automobiles require maintenance that costs $12,900, $500 more than Audi.
- Audi costs $5,400 more to maintain than Lexus, which has a $7,000 maintenance cost. The least expensive premium automobile to maintain is typically a Lexus.
What makes Audi superior to Mercedes?
Audi is a clear choice when it comes to performance and dependability since Mercedes only offers all-wheel drive on a few of its models while Audi is all about it. Speaking of which, Audi proved to be a far more dependable brand than Mercedes in Consumer Reports’ road test.
Which vehicle has more issues? Mercedes or a BMW?
BMW averages 123 issues per vehicle sold, which is more problems per vehicle than Mercedes-Benz. Mercedes-Benz vehicles experience problems more frequently, with 152 issues per 1,000 sold. BMW is more reliable than the typical car. 134 issues are reported for every sold vehicle in the industry.
What makes Mercedes superior to BMW?
If you desire a sporty drive with superior fuel economy statistics, a BMW might be a better option for you. Mercedes vehicles, on the other hand, are renowned for their safety and contain a variety of cutting-edge technology. You are free to make your decision.
If you’re looking for a luxury vehicle, you can’t go wrong with a BMW or a Mercedes. They both have the luxurious features you want and a range of models to choose from.
Audi or BMW costs less to maintain?
“Since the automobiles are still pretty new and don’t require much maintenance, it’s not unexpected that there are fewer quotes within the first five years.
“It’s intriguing to note, though, exactly how much more expensive Audi is compared to the other two models, particularly between the five and eight-year points.
Perhaps customers entering showrooms across the UK will now pause before selecting a brand to invest in.”
Drivers paid PS182.94 on average for Audi repairs in 2017, 11% less than the PS207.11 quoted in 2016.
The C-Class and A4 have the most discrepancy in repair prices between the manufacturers’ corresponding vehicles.
Repair costs for the A4 are 39% greater than those for the C-Class, and it is 28% taller than the BMW 3-Series.
In contrast to Mercedes, which is the most expensive of the three manufacturers for this kind of maintenance, Audi is the least expensive for steering and suspension, electrical, and battery repairs.
With an average cost of PS369.92, Audi is also the least expensive for a cambelt replacement, as opposed to Mercedes, which costs PS475.54 and BMW, which costs PS826.22.
“The reason for this price disparity is because BMW and Mercedes frequently employ timing chains rather than cambelts, which are more costly to fix.
However, Preston noted that requests for BMW and Mercedes timing chain repairs were 20 and 100 times, respectively, less frequent than those for Audi cambelt repairs.
Mercedes clutch replacements were estimated on average at PS670.58, while BMW and Audi were PS544.85 and PS578.39, respectively.
The average cost of an Audi gearbox repair is the highest of the three brands; a manual gearbox repair costs PS567.73, an auto gearbox repair costs PS428.68, and a reconditioned gearbox costs PS744.60.
Around the five-year mark, Audi repair prices start to rise; at this point, Audi is around PS75 more expensive than Mercedes and PS25 more expensive than BMW.
Jeremy has worked as a journalist for 30 years, 20 of them in the automotive B2B sector. Before launching the AM website, he spent three years as a writer and news editor for AM’s sister publication, Fleet News. He has served as Bauer B2B’s head of digital for the past five years, assisting in the management of AM’s digital assets as well as those of Fleet News, Commercial Fleet, Rail, and Smart Transport.
Audi or BMW, which is more comfortable?
BMW’s vehicles, which are made to provide the “ultimate driving experience,” frequently outperform Audi in terms of handling. Because of their overall stronger suspension systems that promote a smooth, pleasant ride, Audi vehicles are significantly less agile than BMW vehicles. BMW typically ranks higher for dependability
Does BMW require less upkeep than Mercedes?
BMWs are by far the most expensive car manufacturer to repair, claims Your Mechanic. The competition is not even close. With an average maintenance cost of $17,800 over ten years, BMW comes in #1. Mercedes-Benz came in second with an average maintenance cost of $12,900 during a 10-year period. In contrast, the typical Toyota only cost $5,500 to maintain during a 10-year period because they are recognized for requiring less maintenance.
According to Your Mechanic, such high maintenance costs are usual in German premium vehicles. Audi comes in sixth with an average $12,400 maintenance expense over a 10-year period. This is primarily a result of the pricey, high-end parts that these luxury vehicles require. Naturally, it will cost a lot of money to fix those pieces when they break or need maintenance.
However, while being premium vehicles, they also have ongoing problems. For instance, according to Your Mechanic, a BMW is four times more likely to not start than a typical automobile. It was ranked seventh overall as a result. Additionally, the window regulator on the BMW required replacement 18 times more frequently than the window regulator on the ordinary car.
BMW or Audi, which lasts longer?
Reliability is another area where BMW outperforms Audi. Recently, all BMW models received expected reliability ratings that were above average. The well-known 5 Series received the highest rating, while the 2 Series, 4 Series, X1 and X4 also earned commendable results. Audi’s grades are significantly lower, and the brand received an average overall rating. Only three of Audi’s 12 models—the A5, A7, and A8—have anticipated reliability ratings that are above average, while the other four received below-average ratings.
Which German vehicle is the most reliable?
Volkswagen and Mercedes-Benz were traditionally thought to be trustworthy brands. BMWs have always been slightly more reliable than average.
BMW receives a 3 out of 5 star rating from Consumer Reports for both new (0–3 year) and used (3–8 year) vehicles. Ownership of a BMW for a year seems to have been a terrible experience for BMW owners, with numerous and aggravating trips to the shop.
BMW is ranked 17th overall by Consumer Reports among all manufacturers. Other luxury automakers like Cadillac and Audi defeated the German brand.
Which German vehicle requires the least maintenance?
- 7 Mini Cooper S models made after 2019.
- 1996 to 2004: 6 Porsche Boxster (986)
- 5 Mercedes SLK (R171/R172) starting in 2004.
- Audi RS4 Sedan (B7), 4 models, 2006–2008.
- 1955 to 1974: 3 Volkswagen Karmann Ghias.
- 2 BMW 325i (E30) – 1982-91.
- a 1991–1995 Porsche 968
Which German company is most trustworthy?
One of the most dependable brands on the international market, Volkswagen is the marquee brand for the Volkswagen Group.
The German government founded Volkswagen in 1937 with the goal of giving the populace a dependable automobile that was inexpensive for the average driver, hence the appellation “people’s vehicle.”
Volkswagen is known for a wide range of vehicles, from beloved family and young driver favorites like the Golf and Polo to legendary movie stars like the Beetle.
The Beetle was so well-liked that it survived in production for decades before finally being stopped in 2018. It was partially created by famed automaker Ferdinand Porsche, who later went on to found his own firm.
Due to their low costs, dependable engineering, roomy interiors, and all the modern amenities that drivers require today, the Golf and Polo continue to be among of the most popular hatchbacks on the market and are steadfast family favorites.