Although both BMW and Audi are very dependable companies, Audi ultimately wins due to its extended warranty coverage and added safety measures.
In This Article...
Final Conclusion
It’s difficult to predict who will win the Audi vs. BMW competition. The same target market is being courted by both producers, but they focus on distinct specifications and features.
When it comes to technology and style, Audi is the winner, but BMW offers a smoother, sportier driving experience. When it comes to safety features, both brands score highly, however Audi has far lower reliability ratings. Although there isn’t much of a difference in price between the two, Audi’s reliability difficulties are evident in the price of repairs.
In the end, they are both fairly similar automobile makers with comparable models that appeal to slightly different demographics. Choose a BMW if you want a sporty, controlled ride. Choose an Audi if you want something with understated style and cutting-edge technology.
Which Brands Require More Upkeep
AM-Online has conducted research and created a number of infographics to show which German brands are the most dependable and affordable to repair. The study compares maintenance requirements for BMW, Audi, and Mercedes-Benz under six years of ownership, after six years, and after twelve years. As a result, this generally illustrates how each automaker’s models are over their whole lives.
Under six years, the cost and dependability of every car is relatively the same. This is due to the fact that the vehicles are relatively new, often have less than 100,000 miles on them, and come with a factory-backed guarantee, meaning that there won’t be many significant problems.
Audi still has the most issues and requires the most money to fix, though. Mercedes is the most dependable and, therefore, the most affordable vehicle, placing BMW in the center. Things start to alter after six years. The cars do have a tendency to break down as they accumulate more kilometers and perhaps more owners.
The least dependable and priciest of the three manufacturers is still Audi, while Mercedes continues to be the market leader and BMW remains in the center. Twelve years later, though, things usually settle down again because the automobiles are so old and most customers choose to ignore minor issues.
But when you get down to the smaller particulars, things get a little messier. It wasn’t as simple to compare different car classes, such as the 1 Series/2 Series class, 3 Series class, and 5 Series class. The brands’ positioning didn’t change, but the expenses to repair various models did. For instance, the less priced models of both BMW and Audi were less expensive to fix, which seems relatively normal. However, Mercedes-more Benz’s expensive models were the cheapest to repair, probably due to their greater build quality and dependability.
which is more trustworthy BMW, Mercedes, or Audi?
You can see that BMW performs far better than Mercedes-Benz or Audi. Additionally, it performs much better than the industry standard of 121 issues per 100 vehicles. Audi and Mercedes-Benz both rank lower than the average number of issues per 100 vehicles, even though Mercedes is close to the industry average.
Which is superior, the Audi or the BMW?
BMW’s vehicles, which are made to provide the “ultimate driving experience,” frequently outperform Audi in terms of handling. Because of their overall stronger suspension systems that promote a smooth, pleasant ride, Audi vehicles are significantly less agile than BMW vehicles. BMW typically ranks higher for dependability
Audi or BMW costs less to maintain?
“Since the automobiles are still pretty new and don’t require much maintenance, it’s not unexpected that there are fewer quotes within the first five years.
“It’s intriguing to note, though, exactly how much more expensive Audi is compared to the other two models, particularly between the five and eight-year points.
Perhaps customers entering showrooms across the UK will now pause before selecting a brand to invest in.”
Drivers paid PS182.94 on average for Audi repairs in 2017, 11% less than the PS207.11 quoted in 2016.
The C-Class and A4 have the most discrepancy in repair prices between the manufacturers’ corresponding vehicles.
Repair costs for the A4 are 39% greater than those for the C-Class, and it is 28% taller than the BMW 3-Series.
In contrast to Mercedes, which is the most expensive of the three manufacturers for this kind of maintenance, Audi is the least expensive for steering and suspension, electrical, and battery repairs.
With an average cost of PS369.92, Audi is also the least expensive for a cambelt replacement, as opposed to Mercedes, which costs PS475.54 and BMW, which costs PS826.22.
“The reason for this price disparity is because BMW and Mercedes frequently employ timing chains rather than cambelts, which are more costly to fix.
However, Preston noted that requests for BMW and Mercedes timing chain repairs were 20 and 100 times, respectively, less frequent than those for Audi cambelt repairs.
Mercedes clutch replacements were estimated on average at PS670.58, while BMW and Audi were PS544.85 and PS578.39, respectively.
The average cost of an Audi gearbox repair is the highest of the three brands; a manual gearbox repair costs PS567.73, an auto gearbox repair costs PS428.68, and a reconditioned gearbox costs PS744.60.
Around the five-year mark, Audi repair prices start to rise; at this point, Audi is around PS75 more expensive than Mercedes and PS25 more expensive than BMW.
Jeremy has worked as a journalist for 30 years, 20 of them in the automotive B2B sector. Before launching the AM website, he spent three years as a writer and news editor for AM’s sister publication, Fleet News. He has served as Bauer B2B’s head of digital for the past five years, assisting in the management of AM’s digital assets as well as those of Fleet News, Commercial Fleet, Rail, and Smart Transport.
Which holds its value better, BMW or Audi?
According to Darryl Jacobson, managing director of True Price, BMW automobiles have the lowest resale value, Mercedes-Benz vehicles are the best, and Audi vehicles fall right in the middle of the two main German automakers in terms of resale value. His conclusions are supported by an examination of True Price data.
How trustworthy are Audi cars?
With a 3.0 out of 5.0 reliability rating, Audi is ranked 28th overall out of 32 auto brands. This evaluation is based on the average of 345 different models. Audis have typical ownership expenses with an average annual maintenance cost of $987. In addition, 0.8 service visits year on average and a 13% chance of a severe repair are other elements that affect how reliable an Audi is.
What are Audis worth?
Apparently, The Drive “The average Audi will cost $12,400 in upkeep over the course of ten years. For comparison, the 10-year averages for popular brands like Toyota, Ford, and Honda are $5,500, $9,100, and $7,200, respectively.”
In the end, Audis cost more to maintain than the ordinary automobile for a number of reasons. You can anticipate greater charges for routine maintenance and some parts if you own an Audi. In addition to being more expensive to repair in general, Audi parts in particular are more expensive.
The upside to this is that they are more dependable than the ordinary car. Audis are reputed to be more dependable when it comes to new cars, but they do have a tendency to develop problems over time, which can be more expensive to replace.
Another thing to think about is insurance. Many Audis cost more to insure than the ordinary car due to their higher level of luxury. A typical year of insurance for an Audi costs $1,606 (USD), which is 36% more than the national average. Additionally, the cost of insurance varies across different models.
Due to the fact that Audi is a European brand, there are fewer parts available, which contributes significantly to the higher insurance costs.
Which European vehicle is the most dependable?
Mercedes-Benz According to Warranty Wise, Mercedes-Benz is the most reliable of the three major German premium brands, and its vehicles are generally more economical to repair.
Which premium German car is the most dependable?
The Porsche 911 is the brand’s most well-known model and the one that most closely embodies its core values. On the roster, it is also the most dependable.
Porsche spent decades refining the sports car formula without significantly altering the architecture. Naturally, Porsche has included cutting-edge suspension systems, more fuel-efficient engines, and new technologies, but without compromising reliability.
Of course, Porsche 911 drivers travel fewer miles than the typical Porsche Macan driver. Even so, more pricey and long-lasting parts keep the popular Porsche sports car dependable, no matter the conditions.
Are Audis costly to repair?
Audis are expensive to maintain as vehicles. The average annual cost of an Audi repair, according to RepairPal, is $987. This is significantly more than the $652 average across all brands. Because Audis are luxury automobiles and employ pricey speciality parts, their routine maintenance expenses are also probably a little more than those of most other types.
If maintained properly, almost any car, even an Audi, may last for many years. Audi owners claim to have kept their cars for up to 150,000 miles.
Audi automobiles do not include maintenance for nothing. Customers can, however, purchase Audi prepaid maintenance contracts. Some Audi dealers might provide free vehicle maintenance protection.
Why do Audis depreciate so quickly?
Audis employ so much technology, which contributes to their depreciation. Modern luxury vehicles come equipped with a variety of cross-device integration features, screens, software infotainment systems, and power options.
Consider the first-generation iPod charger. Do you still recall the white rectangle that could only go one way? Imagine if the integrated sound and climate control system of your automobile came with one of them hanging from it. Apple CarPlay will eventually stop functioning, and that digital tachometer will appear out-of-date and tacky. And that day is quickly approaching.
The radio cannot simply be pulled out and swapped out for a new one. If you own a CD player, you will always own a CD player. Vehicles with sophisticated digital systems are likely to become obsolete quickly given how quickly technology advances. Thus, just to use the things it came with, you need a new automobile every two years.
Why do BMWs lose value so quickly?
Because they are more expensive to begin with and a large portion of this additional cost is attributable to the “intangibles” that come with luxury automobiles, luxury cars degrade faster than regular cars (i.e. the prestige associated with owning a car from a brand like BMW, Audi or Mercedes-Benz).
The extra amenities and performance of a new luxury car aren’t worth the price premium over a basic car, according to the great majority of car buyers. For instance, a new BMW 5 series is probably not worth twice as much as a Toyota Camry to the majority of automobile buyers (although this may surprise petrolheads). For all practical considerations, the Camry is equally as capable of serving as a daily driver; the additional performance and badge status are largely subjective. In fact, because the Toyota has a solid reputation for dependability, many regular car customers prefer it to the BMW.
The gap between new consumers and those who buy used products is fairly wide, which puts downward pressure on prices even though the new buyer may find real value in the intangibles that come with buying a new luxury.
The adage “the bigger they are, the harder they fall” has probably been heard by you. This holds true for the cost of luxury cars as well, particularly luxury sedans.